IDC Press Release: IDC Outlines Immigration Detention and Alternatives to Inter-American Commission on Human Rights

Over 160 IDC member and partner organizations join a thematic hearing to highlight the growing use and concern over immigration detention in the Americas

WASHINGTON D.C. – The International Detention Coalition (IDC), together with 162 co-petitioners will present concerns about the use and practice of immigration detention in a regional thematic hearing today at the 153rd Period of Sessions of the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights.

 

Many countries in the Americas region are in breach of international legal standards to respect and guarantee the right to freedom for undocumented migrants, despite the fact that international human rights standards clearly stipulate that immigration detention is an exceptional measure and should only be used as a last resort in exceptional cases and after all other options have been shown to be inappropriate in the individual case.

 

New IDC research reveals that immigration detention is practiced extensively in the region, with many more countries detaining than just the United States, Canada and Mexico, where the largest numbers of migrants are detained. Current trends show that immigration detention is being used more frequently in the Caribbean and Central America, and to a lesser extent in certain parts of South America, as States attempt to deter increasingly complex and precarious irregular migration.

 

Among the key challenges highlighted in the research are the lack of corresponding respect for human rights and the absence of transparency and oversight in decisions to detain undocumented migrants. Immigration detention remains much less regulated, reviewed and monitored than other forms of depriving a person of their freedom. These findings will be presented in the hearing, which will be accompanied by the personal testimony of a national from Antigua and Barbuda formerly detained for three years in the United States.

 

According to IDC Americas Regional Coordinator, Gisele Bonnici, “In the overwhelming majority of the countries we studied, immigration detention is notoriously plagued by the lack of information and available data, a lack of access to places of detention and a lack of independent monitoring mechanisms. We believe there is an urgent need to raise awareness about detention practices and prevent their expansion regionally. ¨

 

Bonnici says that there are good practices in the region that prevent unnecessary detention: ¨For the first time in this forum, our hearing will also highlight the region’s key positive immigration practices, with notable examples from South America, as well as examples of effective implementation of alternatives to detention”

 

The International Detention Coalition (IDC) is a unique global network, of over 300 civil society organizations and individuals in more than 70 countries, that advocate for, research and provide direct services to refugees, asylum-seekers and migrants affected by immigration detention.  According to IDC Director, Grant Mitchell, “There are a number of difficult challenges in trying to manage large numbers of undocumented migrant women, men, children and families on the move. What we know from international research however is that immigration detention is damaging and not an effective solution to preventing, addressing or managing undocumented migrants.”

 

Worldwide, states are increasingly recognizing the negative impacts that even short periods of detention can have on migrants—especially on particularly vulnerable groups such as children and families. As the Inter-American Court of Human Rights has recently made clear in an Advisory Opinion on the Rights of Children in the Context of Migration, immigration detention is never in the best interests of the child and therefore is always a child rights violation. Rather than resorting to immigration detention, states must “choose alternative measures to detention for the family, which are appropriate to the needs of the children.”

 

The IDC has found a number of effective, community-based alternatives to detention that states are using to effectively manage and protect migrants in the community without the need for detention. These community models vary from transferred guardianship to family and welfare departments and specialized NGOs, shelter and group housing programs, through to case management and supported return and reintegration programs. IDC research has found these practices are on average 80% cheaper than custodial immigration detention while still ensuring compliance with immigration requirements.

 

According to IDC member and co-petitioner Nancy Perez, director of the Mexican organization Sin Fronteras, “We are hoping that today’s event and the exploration of international good practices will be an important starting point to developing new strategies for regional collaboration aimed at finding sustainable solutions and protection for migrants throughout the region.”

 

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights is an agency of the Organization of American States (OAS), and is responsible for the promotion and protection of human rights in the Americas. The 153rd Period of Sessions of the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights will take place in Washington D.C. from October 23 to November 7. A full schedule of the public hearings is available online.

 

View the hearing Immigration Detention and Alternative Measures in the Americas live in English and Spanish here, 10.15am EST, today.

[gview file=”https://idcoalition.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Press-release_301014.pdf”]