On 12 September 2018, in his state of union speech, European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker announced a Recast of the Return Directive to “accelerate the return of irregular migrants,” among a series of measures on migration.
The legislative proposal foresees more immigration detention to “support enforcement of return”, in particular it introduces:
- a requirement for Member States to “allow for an initial detention period of not less than 3 months” of pre-removal detention;
- a new ground for detention where people subject to a returndecision “pose a threat to public order or security”
- 16 common criteria for determining risk of absconding, including broad grounds such as “illegal entry” and lack of financial resources.
Other changes include a new “obligation to cooperate”, a new border procedure and limiting possibilities for voluntary departure and appeals.
The proposals broadly reflect the Commission’s approach in its 2017 policy package which seeks to increase the rate of returns through enforcement-based measures.
These increased measures have been proposed despite well-established and wide-scale concerns that detention is harmful to health and wellbeing and causes unnecessary suffering. In addition, immigration detention is an extremely costly policy that is challenging to implement, and rarely fulfils its objectives.
Numerous alternatives to detention exist that are less costly, and do not risk an infringement on the human rights of migrants. Using engagement, rather than enforcement to build trust and support migrants and enable governments to achieve their compliance and case resolution goals without detention.
For more information:
- Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on common standards and procedures in Member States for returning illegally staying third-country nationals (recast)
- European Commission – Press release: State of the Union 2018 – Commission proposes last elements needed for compromise on migration and border reform
- European Commission releases proposal to recast Return Directive (ECRE, 14 September 2018)
- EU to shore up borders, returnsand migrant detentions (EUobserver, 12 September 2018)
- EU Eyes Beefed-Up Coast Guard to Protect Outside Borders(New York Times 12 September 2018)